PC vs Mac: Cancel or Allow?

Saturday, February 17, 2007

I think the blog title alone gives you a good hint on what I am talking about. Yes, that Mac commercial (hilarious, by the way) where the PC's body-guard prompts for a "Cancel or Allow" on literally everyting PC does.
(If you have not seen this commercial before, then click the "Play" button on the image below)

 While I do think the commercial is very funny (These Mac marketing folks are good, darn good!), I must admit that it goes too far.
Just to set some context, the commercial pokes fun of the new Windows Vista operating system, which hosts a new and improved security system.

Windows Vista does not ask for your permission when you start an application, browse the web, send emails, chat on IM etc. These are recognized by Vista as common tasks that users perform on a daily basis. If Vista did ask for permission on such common tasks this blog would be looking a lot different. Trust me.

So, is "Cancel or Allow" a lie? - Not quite.

Windows Vista, does indeed prompt its users with a "Cancel or Allow" dialog box, but not for everything you do - as the commercial implies. The question to allow or deny, for instance, is only asked when you try and change your network settings, change shared folders permissions, install new softwares and Plug-ins etc. But this is a good thing!

I don't know about you, but I am an IT administrator. Not professionally, silly! At home!
I have to support my wife, daughter, father, mother, in-laws and on and on and on. Everyone I know uses me as their personal IT administrator, for FREE! - What a deal!. 
Most of them are administrators users on their PCs. They are allowed to do anything they desire (and so do hackers) on that system without knowing the concequences; except for calling me in the middle of the night when they can't get to their emails!

So considering the amount of time this feature of Vista is going to save me by not having to support every Dick, Tom and Harry, I can actually tag this commercial as a plain marketing gimmick - A.K.A. a lie!

Having said that, this commerical below is very true!

Sahil Malik, has also written an awesome and funny blog post on this as well.

Filed Under: Shtuff

Comments

Dennis McDonalsUnited StatesDennis McDonals said:

It's totally unreasonable and unfair, but it sure is funny! (Thanks for bringing this to my attention - I never see these tv ads).

Antonio ChagouryUnited StatesAntonio Chagoury said:

Dennis,

Thank you for your comments. Have you seen the latest one about PC's being bloated with Trial Software?

1. Do Macs not have trial software?
2. What is installed on a PC is either user or manufacturer installed (i.e. Dell) - how does this have anything to do with the OS itself? - They clearly are targeting a less "knowledgeable" audience. I mean, come on!
3. The reason why this is more prominent on PCs is simply because PCs represent 95% of the market?

Let's see what comes next...

Search engine optimizationUnited StatesSearch engine optimization said:

Hi,
  Google’s VP Search Products & User Experience, Marissa Mayer, told me in an interview yesterday that essentially, these changes can be thought of as a “new set of gadgets and functionality that augments our existing iGoogle and allows them to be social.” Indeed, there are already thousands of gadgets available in the iGoogle ecosystem, though only a few of them are taking advantage of the new social capabilities as of today.

ff14 gilAlgeriaff14 gil said:

Hello admin, thanks for sharing this blog post..., i found it very useful. Greets, John Black!!!!

Add comment




  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading